Moose Lodge Marriage Buries Litigants

By Doug Chalgian on November 7, 2021

 

In the last few weeks of Lynden’s life, he was heavily medicated and receiving hospice care. Notwithstanding, he showed up for his marriage at the Moose Lodge and soon thereafter visited a lawyer to have his estate plan altered in favor of his new bride.  What Lynden understood about either of these events is the subject of this litigation.

After his death, Lynden’s adult children attack his estate plan on the usual theories:  lack of capacity and undue influence.

The resulting unpublished opinion from the Michigan Court of Appeals illustrates how a marriage can make a case of financial exploitation significantly more difficult.

First, the surviving spouse is entitled to allowances (which can be brought against the estate or trust assets), and an elective share which goes against the probate estate.  That means that even if the litigants are successful in setting aside the contested documents, the surviving spouse still gets a piece of the action.

Second, the presumption of undue influence doesn’t apply.  This is because one requirement for establishing the presumption is that the perpetrator must be in a confidential or fiduciary relationship with the victim, and the law has held that this requirement cannot be established when the alleged perpetrator is the spouse.

It seems, the best course in these cases is to start in Circuit Court with an action to annul the marriage (a step these litigants missed).  But as explained in a prior post, post-death annulment actions are not easy. Click here to read: Capacity to Marry.

Ultimately this case was over almost nothing in terms of assets, driven only by hard feelings between adult children and a surviving non-parent spouse (as is so often the case).  At the trial court level, the surviving spouse wins on summary.  The COA affirms.

Click here to read: Grinnell Family Trust v Jennifer Blumhardt.

356122

mm By: Doug Chalgian
Doug Chalgian

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


Follow Plan To Be 100

Sign up to follow Plan To Be 100 and get notification of new posts!